Maestría en Economía Aplicada · 2026
Batería-como-servicio (Baas) vs. Batería-como-producto (Baap) : economía de bienes duraderos y efectos sobre la oferta de baterías de segunda vida
This master’s thesis examines the economic and strategic effects of Battery-as-a-Product (BaaP) and Battery-as-a-Service (BaaS) business models on the availability and competitiveness of second-life batteries (SLB) for stationary energy storage. The study draws on the durable goods literature and the logic of strategic interaction under Nash equilibrium, recognizing that contractual access to the battery changes risk allocation, residual value, and asset traceability (Bulow, 1982; Waldman, 2003; Gibbons, 1992). The thesis analysis is organized into four modules. The first compares the total cost of ownership (TCO) for the user under the battery-as-a-product and battery-as-a-service schemes, showing that a reduction in the price of a new pack tends to increase the relative attractiveness of purchasing. The second estimates the potential flow of second-life batteries using a stock–flow approach based on the diffusion of electric vehicles and the distribution of retirements. The third contrasts the levelized cost of storage (LCOS) between new batteries and repurposed batteries, showing that a lower initial CAPEX does not necessarily guarantee a lower levelized cost when refurbishment costs, replacements, and lower usable energy delivered are present (Schmidt et al., 2019; Steckel et al., 2021). The fourth represents the strategic interaction between the manufacturer, the user, and the government, showing that, without public intervention, the equilibrium favors BaaP, while traceability policies, standards, and extended producer responsibility can shift the equilibrium toward BaaS/SLB (European Commission, 2023; Harper et al., 2019). The thesis concludes that SLB competitiveness depends not only on technology and cost drivers but also on institutional conditions that facilitate coordination and efficient asset recovery.
Texto completo 84 páginas con texto
Leer la tesis completa Ficha en el repositorio
Contenido
- SIGLASp. 7
- INTRODUCCIÓNp. 9
- PLANTEAMIENTO DEL PROBLEMA Y JUSTIFICACIÓNp. 12
- OBJETIVOSp. 15
- MARCO TEÓRICOp. 17
- ESTRUCTURA DE ANÁLISISp. 24
- MÓDULO A: TCO DEL CONSUMIDOR (BaaS vs BaaP)p. 24
- MÓDULO B: STOCK – FLUJO SLBp. 40
- MÓDULO C: LCOS-SLB Y ESTRUCTURA – COSTO - DESEMPEÑO (ECD)p. 47
- MÓDULO D: JUEGO ESTRATÉGICO (F, G, U)p. 59
- CONCLUSIONESp. 72
- REFERENCIASp. 74
- ANEXOSp. 78
- Ilustración 1. Ppack (BaaP) vs Fee (BaaS)p. 33
- Ilustración 2. Túnel de Viabilidad para el Valor Presente del Fee (BaaS)p. 37
- Ilustración 3. Stock y Ventas de EV 2010 – 2024p. 45
- Ilustración 4. Retiros de EV y Potencial SLB 2010 – 2024p. 46
- Ilustración 5. Simulación LCOS vs LCOS-SLBp. 53
- Tabla 1. Variables utilizadas en el estudiop. 30
- (MY) 2011–2023p. 31
- Tabla 3. Cálculo del VP_Fee 2011–2024p. 32
- Tabla 4. Sensibilidad de las variables sobre VP del Fee (BaaS)p. 35
- Tabla 5. Precio del Pack de baterías por kWhp. 36
- Tabla 6. Ventas de EV y BEV vs Stock, 2010–2024p. 43
- Tabla 7. Cálculo de SLB Potencia usando Weibull 2010 - 2023p. 45
- Tabla 8. Parámetros y escenarios para cálculo de LCOS y LCOS-SLBp. 52
- Tabla 9. Cuadro Comparativo entre BaaS y BaaPp. 56
- Tabla 10. Escenario de Pagos sin intervención del Gobiernop. 65
- Tabla 11. Matriz de Pagos sin intervención del Gobiernop. 65
- Tabla 12. Escenario de Pagos con intervención del Gobiernop. 67
- Tabla 13. Matriz de Pagos con intervención del Gobiernop. 68
- Tabla 14. Propuestas de instrumentos de política públicap. 70