Derecho · 2026
La gestación subrogada en Colombia : análisis crítico desde la dignidad humana y el derecho contractual
This monograph analyzes surrogacy from its different perspectives and challenges in relation to human dignity within a legal and ethical context framed by contract law. Human dignity is a fundamental principle enshrined in the Colombian Constitution that demands respect for the fundamental rights of all subjects involved in the surrogacy process, which include the gestational mother, the intended parents, and the nasciturus 5 (the unborn child/children). The main objective of this research is to analyze the different perspectives on surrogacy in Colombia, including how human dignity and autonomy of the will are implicated in this process, and how the lack of regulation may violate the rights of the parties, especially the rights of the gestational mother and the unborn child. This research argues that the protection of human dignity implies ensuring that surrogacy is carried out ethically, avoiding exploitation, and securing the protection of all parties' rights. From a legal perspective, there are gaps since it is not regulated in Colombia and other countries. To this extent, Judgment T-968 of 2009 is taken as a basis, where the Constitutional Court first defined surrogacy in Colombia. However, the jurisprudence falls short of protecting the autonomy and dignity of the gestational mother, which leads to its analysis from a contractual perspective. Furthermore, from a juridical-bioethical perspective, human dignity is conceived as a fundamental principle that demands respect for the autonomy, integrity, and inherent rights of every person, especially in contexts involving reproductive decisions. This conception guides the interpretation and application of norms, ensuring that the legal framework aligns with the values of equality, justice, and the protection of fundamental rights. This paper argues that the lack of regulation of surrogacy in Colombia could violate the protection of the rights of the unborn child in terms of determining filiation (legal parentage) and the protection of the nasciturus's rights through surrogacy. Therefore, it is essential to ensure the protection of the rights of the child conceived through this process, 6 as well as to consider the autonomy and dignity of the gestational mother, avoiding any form of exploitation.
Texto completo 127 páginas con texto
Leer la tesis completa Ficha en el repositorio
Contenido
- Resumenp. 3
- Introducciónp. 7
- Contexto y justificaciónp. 7
- Objetivosp. 10
- Objetivo Generalp. 10
- Objetivos Específicosp. 10
- Capítulo 1. Alquiler de vientres en Colombia: antecedentes y marco normativo actualp. 11
- 2.1 Análisis jurisprudencial de la Sentencia T-968 de 2009p. 11
- Resumen del casop. 11
- Disputa judicial y argumentos de las partesp. 12
- Problemas jurídicosp. 13
- Análisis jurídicop. 19
- 2.2 Desarrollo de la línea jurisprudencial sobre la gestación subrogada en Colombiap. 21
- Capítulo 2. Los desafíos jurídicos y éticos en la gestación subrogada en el contexto colombianop. 34
- 3.1 Ética y gestación subrogadap. 34
- Vulneración del recién nacido: de sujeto de derechos a objeto mercantilp. 48
- Vulneración a la gestantep. 56
- Vulneración a los sujetos contratantes: los comitentesp. 65
- Capítulo 3. El contrato de gestación subrogada en Colombiap. 68
- 4.1 Regulación de los contratos atípicos en Colombia y las cláusulas esencialesp. 71
- 4.2 Consentimiento de las partes y licitud de la gestación subrogada en los contratosp. 85
- partes involucradasp. 98
- Cláusulas especiales a fin de protección de los derechos del menorp. 98
- Cláusulas de protección integral a la mujer gestantep. 104
- Cláusulas de protección y responsabilidades de los comitentesp. 109
- Conclusionesp. 113
- Referenciasp. 117