Maestría en Derecho · 2021
La seguridad jurídica en el impuesto de renta en Colombia : periodo 2014 a 2020 : el caso de las personas naturales residentes
Legal certainty is a fundamental principle and value of the rule of law. In Colombia it is important because it is a Constitutional and supranational principle, it generates stability, certainty and optimism in the internal order to comply with its regulations. In this paper, the income tax of a natural person residing in Colombia is analyzed, that is, a direct, mutable and optimal tax for tax collection, which directly affects the finances of people residing in Colombia. The period between the years 2014 to 2020 was selected, not only because of its relevance, but also because of the high number of tax reforms materialized in the laws 1739 of the year 2014, 1819 of the year 2016, 1943 of the year 2018 and 2010 of the year 2019. which would allow a better image of security or legal insecurity to be achieved. In order to achieve greater investigative rigor about the security or legal insecurity present in this set of reforms, the dogmatic methodology was used through which the laws of the four tax reforms were systematically analyzed. In particular, for each law the applicable content for a natural person was identified, the descriptive type and its respective scope were compared. Then, through Humberto Ávila's legal security assessment methodology, the degree of legal security was obtained in the income tax period 2014 to 2020 for a natural person residing in Colombia, for this the three indicators were taken (Cognizability, Calculability and Reliability) and each indicator was divided into four sub-parameters as follows: Cognizability (normative accessibility, normative scope, intellectual understanding of the rules, material understanding of the rules), Calculability (Lex stricta, Lex previa, Transition between tax reforms, firmness) and Reliability (Permanence, determined time, non-retroactivity of the law, effectiveness). The assessment of each indicator was obtained from the sum of the result of the assessment of their respective sub-parameters. The assessment of each subparameter was achieved through qualitative and quantitative qualification. Thus, this research concluded that the assessment of legal security in the natural person income tax in the country, resulted in legal uncertainty between the years 2014 to 2020, therefore, direct and indirect effects were generated against the taxpayers. The permanent mutation threatens the legal security expected by natural persons, a situation that violates the taxpayer's right with respect to legal security, due process, stability and simplicity of the tax system.
Full text 141 pages with text
Read the full thesis Record in the repository
Contents
- Introducciónp. 10
- Algunas noticias jurídicasp. 11
- Marco referencialp. 21
- Marco conceptualp. 21
- Calificación tributariap. 22
- Contribuyentep. 24
- Impuesto de rentap. 26
- Persona naturalp. 29
- Residentep. 30
- Reforma tributariap. 34
- Sujeto pasivop. 35
- Seguridad Jurídicap. 36
- Marco teóricop. 40
- Cognoscibilidadp. 43
- Calculabilidadp. 44
- Confiabilidadp. 46
- Marco normativop. 47
- investigaciónp. 21
- Ley 1739 de 2014p. 50
- Ley 1819 de 2016p. 55
- Ley 1943 de 2018p. 63
- Ley 2010 de 2019p. 65
- Marco Metodológicop. 72
- Las incertidumbres de la inseguridad jurídicap. 74
- Cognoscibilidadp. 43
- Calculabilidadp. 44
- Confiabilidadp. 46
- en Colombia, aplicado a cada ley, por indicador y sus respectivos subparámetros:p. 78
- Ley 1739 de 2014 - Indicador Cognoscibilidadp. 78
- Ley 1739 de 2014 – Indicador Calculabilidadp. 82
- Ley 1739 de 2014 – Indicador Confiabilidadp. 85
- Ley 1819 de 2016 - Indicador Cognoscibilidadp. 87
- Ley 1819 de 2016 – Indicador Calculabilidadp. 90
- Ley 1819 de 2016 - Indicador Confiabilidadp. 92
- Ley 1943 de 2018p. 63
- Ley 1943 de 2018- Indicador Cognoscibilidadp. 95
- Ley 1943 de 2018- Indicador Calculabilidadp. 97
- Ley 1943 de 2018- Indicador Confiabilidadp. 99
- Ley 2010 de 2019 – Indicador Cognoscibilidadp. 101
- Ley 2010 de 2019 - Indicador Calculabilidadp. 103
- Ley 2010 de 2019 – Indicador Confiabilidadp. 105
- Balance de los hallazgosp. 108
- Conclusionesp. 115
- Referenciasp. 119
- Tabla 1. Cambios realizados por la Ley 1819 de 2016p. 57
- Colombiap. 108
- Tabla 4. Tasas impositivas del impuesto de renta persona natural en Sur Américap. 113
- efectos fiscalesp. 32
- Ilustración 2. Clasificación de personas naturales residentes y no residentesp. 33
- naturales: efecto por tipo de medida (Año gravable 2013)p. 53
- naturales: efecto por tipo de contribuyente (Año gravable 2013)p. 54
- propuestosp. 54
- Ilustración 6. Tarifas efectivas de imporrenta persona natural (%)p. 62
- a la cual pertenezca la persona naturalp. 79
- (ORDINARIO, IMAN, IMAS) año gravable 2015 y 2016p. 80