Derecho · 2026
Menores o criminales : el eterno retorno al debate sobre la edad de imputabilidad en Colombia tras el caso Miguel Uribe Turbay
Record only. The repository marks this work as “Acceso abierto”: the PDF is not public, so there is no text to read here. View the record in the repository.
Abstract
This paper examines the renewed debate on the age of criminal responsibility in Colombia after the Miguel Uribe Turbay case, not as an isolated event or a merely emotional controversy, but as evidence of a long-standing institutional tension. Colombia has not fully resolved how to respond to serious harm committed by adolescents while still recognizing their developmental condition and their special constitutional protection. The study argues that the issue cannot be reduced to a binary opposition between minors and criminals. That framing is politically powerful, but it obscures the constitutional, statutory and international foundations of the Juvenile Criminal Responsibility System. Drawing on Law 1098 of 2006, constitutional case law, the standards of the Committee on the Rights of the Child and comparative experiences, the paper shows that the core problem is not only the minimum age of criminal responsibility, but the gap between the restorative promise of the system and what victims, families and communities actually perceive. The main thesis is that the most legally consistent path is not to transfer adolescents to the adult criminal system, but to materially reform the juvenile system so that sanctions become protective, educational, restorative, measurable and socially credible.