Maestría en Ingeniería · 2015
Diagnostic study on shape perception errors within 3D-modeling courses
Form has always been a central concern for design -- Several tools and strategies have been developed aiming to support form generation from different perspectives -- And these issues are also a matter of study for design education -- Under this view, it is relevant to explore how technology and new interactions can aid design students to better understand form generation -- The present study, therefore, is centered on the 3D-modeling courses (ID0245-Modelación 3D1 and ID0267- Modelación 3D2) and tools (PTC® Creo 3.0™) provided inside the Product Design Engineering syllabus at EAFIT University -- In the ever changing academic world, new generations of students will be always in need of new methodological approaches from educators, in order to better understand the knowledge they are being given -- Curriculum adaptations will be always necessary to achieve this goal -- Therefore, the scope of the present study aims to set the ground for new teaching strategies around the 3D-modeling courses, based on the most commonly identified errors and difficulties found in 3D-modeling students -- These errors or difficulties might not be isolated factors, only present in the named courses -- They can be intrinsically connected with the acquired skills from other form generation-related courses, such as Drawing and Projects (where physical model are built and techniques are introduced by guidance) -- However, since the project is framed by the mentioned 3D-modeling tools and courses, it is necessary to understand how form is being generated inside 3D digital environments as a starting point for future work -- Nowadays, individual software provide increasing capabilities to help achieving specific modeling tasks -- This segmentation and specialization demands high expertize from users to become accustomed and keep up with the ever demanding industry standards -- Nonetheless, speed and quality cannot be compromised -- Hence, the main target around the study will be design students that take their first steps towards product embodiment -- The project, therefore, aims to understand how students approach styling activities and to report on their most common mistakes -- It is based on how they perceive 2D representations of products and how accurate their 3D-models are, based on selected shape properties -- This will serve as an essential input for new teaching strategies towards students’ self-awareness when performing in 3D form-giving environments
Full text 163 pages with text out of 170
Read the full thesis Record in the repository
Contents
- Introductionp. 21
- 1.1. Backgroundp. 22
- 1.2. Justificationp. 26
- 1.3. Objectivesp. 28
- 1.3.1. General objectivep. 28
- 1.3.2. Specific objectivesp. 28
- 1.4. Scopep. 29
- 1.5. Structurep. 29
- Theoretical frameworkp. 31
- 2.1. Aesthetics and form-givingp. 32
- 2.1.1. Aesthetic product designp. 33
- 2.1.2. Positive aesthetic evaluationp. 34
- 2.1.3. What is styling?p. 34
- 2.2. Approaches towards form generationp. 37
- 2.2.1. The Problem-Solving Process and Form Generation Modelp. 38
- 2.2.2. Spatial thinking and visualizationp. 42
- 2.2.3. Perceptual approachp. 43
- 2.2.4. Methodological approachp. 49
- 2.2.5. Stylistic approachp. 54
- 2.3. 3D modeling, CAD and CASp. 56
- 2.3.1. What is CAS?p. 58
- 2.3.2. CAS system characteristicsp. 61
- 2.3.3. Design features and CAS field issuesp. 63
- 2.4. Visual perception and shape componentsp. 67
- 2.4.1. Sketching and observationp. 68
- 2.4.2. Image matching and object recognitionp. 72
- Methodologyp. 77
- 3.1. Project contextp. 78
- 3.2. Surveysp. 84
- 3.3. Selection of visual perception errors typesp. 89
- 3.4. Tests designp. 95
- Implementation and resultsp. 103
- 4.1. Observations on students’ deliverablesp. 103
- 4.2. Results: Test 1p. 117
- 4.3. Results: Test 2p. 119
- 4.4. Results: Test 3p. 124
- 4.4.1. Errors’ patterns and clustersp. 124
- 4.4.2. Modeling profiles’ proposalp. 128
- Conclusions and future workp. 133
- Referencesp. 137
- Appendix A: The Problem-Solving Process and Form Generation Modelp. 151
- Appendix B: Survey’s fact sheetp. 155
- Appendix C: Deviation percentages and outcomesp. 164
- 10. Appendix D: 3D-modeling profiles’ sample and rankingp. 168
- Figure 1. CAS within the product design process. Adapted from (Dankwort et al., 2004)p. 24
- al., 1992)p. 39
- model. Adapted from (Wallschlaeger et al., 1992)p. 41
- (Oxman, 2002)p. 44
- Figure 5. Design process summarized as Express, Test and Cycle. Adopted from (McKim, 1972)p. 45
- Figure 6. McKim's model of visual thinking. Adopted from (McKim, 1972)p. 46
- Figure 7. Automotive industry styling workflow. Adapted from (Catalano et al., 2002)p. 51
- 1998)p. 57
- Figure 9. Styling attributes for a rule-base system. Adapted from (Chen & Owen, 1998)p. 57
- Figure 11. Some design features. Adapted from (Giannini et al., 2004)p. 64
- Figure 12. Issue of ambiguity from 2D to 3D transition. Adapted from (Masry & Lipson, 2007)p. 64
- Figure 13. Morphology (a) and Topology (b) features. Adapted from (Cheutet et al., 2005)p. 65
- et al., 1999)p. 66
- Adapted from (Adams, 2013)p. 68
- Figure 16. Lewis and Peacocke’s views on Visual Experience. Adapted from (Fish, 2013)p. 69
- schemas. Adapted from (Prats et al., 2009)p. 71
- Figure 18. Object recognition workflow. Adapted from (Biederman, 1987)p. 73
- Figure 19. Shape regions within the whole. Adapted from (Guerrero et al., 2015)p. 74
- course material)p. 81
- (www.alessi.com/it)p. 81
- Modelación 3D2 course material)p. 81
- Alessi (www.alessi.com/it)p. 81
- using Boundary Blend PTC®p. 82
- Figure 25. Example of Style surface using object boundaries PTC®p. 83
- Figure 26. Example of imported images for 3D spatial referencep. 83
- Figure 27. Example of divergence between student's own perception and his/her outcomesp. 85
- CAS dedicated activitiesp. 85
- activitiesp. 86
- Figure 30. Styling competence in terms of aesthetic errors' awareness and image fidelityp. 87
- coursep. 88
- Figure 32. Students' preference for different 3D-modeling approachesp. 89
- Figure 33. Product's body modeling using "Mirror" featurep. 91
- Figure 34. Selected shape properties for students' performance evaluationp. 92
- Figure 35. Alessi's Piripicchio measures. (Alessi. General Catalog 2013)p. 96
- Figure 36. Proportions accuracy through reference dimensionp. 96
- Figure 37. Summary of the products used to test students' performancep. 97
- Figure 38. Shape properties used for evaluation within one of the test productsp. 99
- Figure 39. Summary layout of a group of students evaluated using the Piripicchio, by Alessip. 100
- productp. 35
- Figure 41. Example of student performance across different productsp. 102
- Figure 42. Product #1: S Table. Perspective and top viewsp. 105
- Figure 43. Evaluation features for Product #1p. 105
- Figure 44. Product #2: Moby. Side viewp. 106
- Figure 45. Examples of additional images for detailing Skip Hop® Mobyp. 107
- Figure 46. Evaluation features for Product #2p. 107
- selected product (right)p. 108
- Figure 48. Evaluation features for Product #3p. 109
- Figure 49. Product #4: Alessi's Piripicchiop. 110
- Figure 50. Alessi's Piripicchio available web reference images: side, front and rear viewsp. 111
- Figure 51. Evaluation features for Product #4p. 112
- Figure 52. Product #5: Water can. Rendered perspective representationp. 113
- Figure 53. Side and top view of a water canp. 113
- Figure 54. Evaluation features for Product #5p. 114
- Figure 55. Product #6: Bike seat. Isometric and orthogonal viewsp. 115
- Figure 56. Evaluation features for Product #6p. 116
- Figure 57. Students' performance for Product #1p. 117
- Figure 58. Summary of students' performance for Test 1p. 118
- Figure 59. Students average deviation in Product #4p. 119
- Figure 60. Students average deviation in Product #5p. 120
- Figure 61. Students average deviation in Product #6p. 120
- Figure 62. Students average deviation across products for Test 2p. 121
- Figure 63. Deviation difference between Test 1 and Test 2p. 122
- Figure 64. Students total average across products for Test 1 and Test 2p. 122
- Figure 65. Example comparison between low (left) and high (right) deviation percentagesp. 123
- Figure 66. Analysis approach based on graphics' similarityp. 125
- Figure 67. Students' clustering based on worst performance on Radius propertyp. 126
- Figure 68. Students' clustering based on worst performance on Length propertyp. 126
- propertyp. 100
- Profilep. 129
- Profilep. 130
- Profilep. 131
- Figure 73. Student´s academic semester samplep. 155
- Figure 74. Students’ self-perceived capacity to design a product´s (aesthetic) shapep. 156
- Figure 75. Students’ preferred design-related activitiesp. 156
- Figure 76. Students’ preferred form-giving activitiesp. 157
- Figure 77. Students’ preferred course-related set of toolsp. 157
- Figure 78. Students’ preferred 3D-modeling approachesp. 158
- Figure 79. Students’ perceived ease of usage, for 3D tools or modulesp. 158
- Figure 80. Students’ perceived control over the 4 viewport windowsp. 159
- Figure 81. Students' perceived own skill for drawing (mean value of 7.1 over 10)p. 159
- Figure 84. Students' perceived own skill for prototyping (mean value of 8.1 over 10)p. 161
- over 10)p. 161
- Figure 86. Students' perceived software ease of use (mean value of 7.8 over 10)p. 162
- Figure 87. Students' awareness of aesthetic mistakes (mean value of 8.1 over 10)p. 162
- Figure 88. Students' awareness of aesthetic mistakes (mean value of 6.9 over 10)p. 163
- Seatp. 166
- Table 1. Styling definitions across authors and fieldsp. 35
- productp. 35
- Table 3. Example of a student performance evaluationp. 100
- Table 4. Description of shape features' relational measures for Product #1p. 106
- Table 5. Description of shape features' relational measures for Product #2p. 108
- Table 6. Description of shape features' relational measures for Product #3p. 109
- Table 7. Description of shape features' relational measures for Product #4p. 112
- Table 8. Description of shape features' relational measures for Product #5p. 114
- Table 9. Description of shape features' relational measures for Product #6p. 116
- rankingp. 169
- Table 11. The Problem-Solving Process and Form Generation Model (Spanish translation)p. 152
- Table 12. Sample group for Test 3 sorted by their assigned numberp. 169
- Table 13. Sample group for Test 3 sorted by their ranking positionp. 170