Medellín - Minas - Doctorado en Ingeniería - Sistemas · 2024
Essentia Curriculum : curriculum design from a software engineering approach based on the SEMAT essence kernel
Some curriculum design methods are found by considering a literature review of a century of curriculum design theory; however, documented experiences worldwide indicate curriculum design is done without considering curriculum design methods based on theory. In this vein, this Ph.D. Thesis starts by observing the practices described in curriculum design theory differ from empirical practices, an observation leading to many ways of working. Further, experiences in curriculum design lack documentation, and observable and reliable verification about curriculum design practices from an engineering perspective is lacking. Dealing with such gaps, this Ph.D. Thesis is focused on creating a theoretical foundation for curriculum design—initially focused on computing-related academic programs—from a software engineering approach by using the Software Engineering Method and Theory (SEMAT) Essence kernel. Thus, we establish ESSENTIA CURRICULUM in this work. To this end, a linguistic corpus is constructed based on a literature review and contributions from a community of 226 professors with experience in curriculum design worldwide. First, the work focuses on eliciting common practices. Second, the terminology is unified. Third, we propose modifications to the SEMAT Essence kernel for establishing EC-Nucleus as the core of ESSENTIA CURRICULUM, which is the basis of a language specification easy to understand, and context-free. Thus, EC-Nucleus can be applied beyond computing-related academic programs. ESSENTIA CURRICULUM is based on computational linguistics analysis of the linguistic corpus, which allows for the identification of common practices and, consequently, the unification of the terminology to support curriculum design endeavors. Ten common practices are represented in ESSENTIA CURRICULUM. Such practices and some curriculum design representations proposed by the community constitute a growing library of practices called EC-Bibliotheca, which is available online. Finally, the proposal is validated in an academic scenario with favorable results by following the IEEE 1012-2016 standard. The ESSENTIA CURRICULUM has the basis for creating specialized computing solutions working on natural language processing in future scenarios due to its definition as a system, theory, method, and model. (Tomado de la fuente)
Full text 141 pages with text out of 142
Read the full thesis Record in the repository
Contents
- General aspects of the researchp. 15
- Abstractp. 15
- Justificationp. 15
- Goalsp. 16
- Methodologyp. 17
- Literature reviewp. 13
- Problem statementp. 32
- Theoretical frameworkp. 34
- SEMAT Essencep. 34
- SEMAT Essence in educational scenariosp. 36
- Pre-conceptual schemasp. 39
- Building a theoretical foundationp. 41
- Terminology unificationp. 41
- System validation and verificationp. 42
- Additional materialp. 44
- 4.7.1 Action Design Research (ADR)p. 44
- 4.7.2 SEMAT Essence-based researchp. 45
- 4.7.3 Delphi data collectionp. 47
- Research development and proposed solutionp. 49
- Identifying common itemsp. 49
- Creating a linguistic corpusp. 55
- Eliciting common practicesp. 59
- Unifying terminologyp. 67
- Proposing modifications to the SEMAT Essence kernelp. 125
- Representing common practices in ESSENTIA CURRICULUMp. 82
- Forming a library of practices represented in ESSENTIA CURRICULUMp. 94
- Verification and validationp. 97
- Verification process on ESSENTIA CURRICULUMp. 101
- Validation process on ESSENTIA CURRICULUMp. 103
- CURRICULUMp. 73
- Conclusions, contributions, and future workp. 123
- Conclusionsp. 123
- Contributionsp. 126
- Future workp. 123
- Figure 2-1: Systematic Literature Review protocol based on (Zapata & Baron, 2016)p. 19
- Figure 2-2: Systematic literature review, sources, criteria, and findingsp. 21
- Figure 2-3: Timeline of a century of curriculum design theoryp. 21
- Figure 2-4: Authors included a century of curriculum design theoryp. 22
- Figure 2-5: The curriculum spider web (van den Akker et al., 2006)p. 23
- Figure 2-6: Curriculum design proposed by Desai and von der Embse (2001)p. 24
- Figure 2-7: Curriculum design proposed by Burkett (2002)p. 25
- Figure 2-8: Curriculum design proposed by Ehie (2002)p. 25
- Figure 2-9: Curriculum design proposed by Golden and Matos (2006)p. 26
- Figure 2-10: Curriculum design proposed by Ding et al. (2011)p. 26
- Figure 2-11: Curriculum design proposed by Wang et al. (2011)p. 27
- Figure 2-12: Curriculum design translated from Martínez and Luna (2012)p. 27
- Figure 2-13: Curriculum design proposed by Nakayama (2015)p. 28
- (2013)p. 28
- Figure 2-15: Curriculum design translated from Villapol et al. (2013)p. 29
- Figure 2-16: Curriculum design proposed by Fichman et al. (2014)p. 29
- Figure 2-17: Curriculum design adapted from Espinosa et al. (2016)p. 30
- Figure 2-18: Curriculum design proposed by Ristov et al. (2016)p. 30
- Figure 2-19: Curriculum design translated from Ontiveros and Antolinez (2013)p. 31
- Figure 2-20: List of some curriculum design graphic representationsp. 31
- Figure 3-1: The gap between what theory says and what designers really dop. 32
- Figure 3-2: Current perspective of curriculum designers. Source: pbs.twimg.comp. 33
- Figure 4-1: Areas of concern and ALPHAs in SEMAT Essence (OMG, 2018)p. 35
- Figure 4-2: Activity Spaces in the SEMAT Essence (OMG, 2018)p. 35
- Figure 4-3: Competencies in the SEMAT Essence (OMG, 2018)p. 36
- Figure 4-4: Pre-conceptual schema notation based on Noreña (2020)p. 39
- Jaramillo (2018)p. 40
- Figure 4-6: Building theoretical foundation based on Swanson and Chermack (2013)p. 41
- Figure 4-7: Verification and validation processes (Mangeruca, 2017)p. 43
- Figure 5-1: Common items between practices of curriculum designp. 50
- Figure 5-2: Scenarios for curriculum design based on IBE-UNESCO (2017)p. 51
- Akker (2003)p. 52
- Figure 5-5: Excerpt of the potential list of participants in the “Call of Action.”p. 53
- Figure 5-6: 226 professors worldwide who participated in the surveyp. 53
- Figure 5-7: Identifying van den Akker’s components in papers and survey responsesp. 54
- Figure 5-8: Sources of the linguistic corpusp. 55
- Figure 5-9: First representation of the linguistic corpus using a word cloudp. 56
- Figure 5-10: 3D space cluster of the relevant concepts in the linguistic corpusp. 57
- Figure 5-11: Cluster analysis to elicit codes from the linguistic corpusp. 58
- Figure 5-12: Excerpt of a collocation analysis from the linguistic corpusp. 59
- Figure 5-13: Structure of items based on elicited codes from the corpusp. 60
- Figure 5-14: Usage of the common items in the linguistic corpusp. 61
- corpusp. 62
- Figure 5-16: Excerpts of common items distributed in curriculum design practicesp. 63
- Figure 5-18: Excerpts of the practice-related sentencesp. 64
- Figure 5-19: Samples of syntax analysis applied to a practice-related statementp. 65
- schemas and a summary of the verbs, nouns, and adjectivesp. 66
- Figure 5-21: Distribution of the 10 common practicesp. 67
- (2014)p. 68
- characterization of a practice based on Barón (2019)p. 69
- Figure 5-24: Process of semantic association based on ISO 704:2009p. 70
- Figure 5-25: Comparing different scenariosp. 72
- Figure 5-26: Quintessence kernel based on Henao (2018)p. 72
- Figure 5-27: The Quintessence kernel based on Henao (2018)p. 73
- Figure 5-28: EC-Nucleus based on the Quintessence kernelp. 74
- Henao (2018)p. 75
- OMG (2018) and Henao (2018)p. 76
- OMG (2018), Henao (2018), and Durango et al. (2019)p. 78
- Figure 5-32: Work products in ESSENTIA CURRICULUM, inspired by OMG (2018)p. 78
- Figure 5-33: Language specification of ESSENTIA CURRICULUMp. 80
- specificationp. 82
- methodp. 83
- Figure 5-36: Common practice 1 – Detailed finding of the participantsp. 84
- studentsp. 85
- Figure 5-38: Common practice 3 – Educational application of knowledgep. 86
- Figure 5-39: Common practice 4 – Accurate analysis of the needsp. 87
- outcomesp. 88
- Figure 5-41: Common practice 6 – Balanced organization of the structure/contentp. 89
- experiencesp. 90
- Figure 5-43: Common practice 8 – Structured establishment of the assessmentp. 91
- Figure 5-44: Common practice 9 – Sufficient support of materialsp. 92
- Figure 5-45: Common practice 10 – Learned feedback from the curriculum designp. 93
- Figure 5-46: EC-Bibliotheca as a digital repositoryp. 94
- Figure 6-1: ESSENTIA CURRICULUM as a systemp. 98
- Figure 6-2: Applying the IEEE 1012-2016 standard for verification and validationp. 98
- (2023)p. 99
- levelsp. 100
- Figure 6-5: Two key areas for verification and validation, respectivelyp. 100
- p. 65)p. 101
- Figure 6-7: Components of the requirements engineering documentationp. 102
- CURRICULUMp. 73
- 68)p. 103
- Figure 6-11: Excerpt of the early works on interpreting theoretical constructsp. 105
- represented in ESSENTIA CURRICULUM, part 1p. 106
- represented in ESSENTIA CURRICULUM, part 2p. 107
- CURRICULUMp. 73
- Figure 6-15: Validating the coherence on experiencing ESSENTIA CURRICULUMp. 107
- Figure 6-16: Validating the ease of use on experiencing ESSENTIA CURRICULUMp. 108
- Figure 6-17: Final comments on experiencing ESSENTIA CURRICULUMp. 108
- common practicep. 110
- Figure 6-19: A sample of semantic equivalent analysis by using PCS-AI v1.0p. 111
- with the ESSENTIA CURRICULUM common practicesp. 114
- Figure 6-22: Kilpatric’s method (1918) represented in ESSENTIA CURRICULUMp. 115
- Figure 6-23: Bobbitt’s method (1924) represented in ESSENTIA CURRICULUMp. 116
- Figure 6-24: Charters’ method (1929) represented in ESSENTIA CURRICULUMp. 116
- Figure 6-25: Rugg’s method (1930) represented in ESSENTIA CURRICULUMp. 116
- CURRICULUMp. 73
- Figure 6-27: Tyler’s method (1949) represented in ESSENTIA CURRICULUMp. 117
- CURRICULUMp. 73
- Figure 6-29: Taba’s method (1962) represented in ESSENTIA CURRICULUMp. 118
- Figure 6-30: Kerr’s method (1968) represented in ESSENTIA CURRICULUMp. 118
- CURRICULUMp. 73
- Figure 6-32: Stenhouse’s method (1975) represented in ESSENTIA CURRICULUMp. 119
- Figure 6-33: Bruner’s method (1977) represented in ESSENTIA CURRICULUMp. 119
- Figure 6-34: Walters’ method (1978) represented in ESSENTIA CURRICULUMp. 119
- Figure 6-35: Grayson’s method (1979) represented in ESSENTIA CURRICULUMp. 120
- Figure 6-36: Perkins’ method (1998) represented in ESSENTIA CURRICULUMp. 120
- CURRICULUMp. 73
- CURRICULUMp. 73
- CURRICULUMp. 73
- CURRICULUMp. 73
- Figure 7-1: ESSENTIA CURRICULUM at a glancep. 124
- Table 1-1: Curriculum levels and curriculum products (van den Akker et al., 2006)p. 23
- Table 6-1: The semantic equivalence analysis results using PCS-AI v1.0p. 112
- CURRICULUM common practicesp. 113
- theoryp. 115